“Gimmick Commerce” is one way to look at the sites that entice people to buy things online via promotions, flash sales and subscriptions. Mostly, it represents things that people don’t need.
But it has almost totally failed, per Recode’s Jason Del Rey in a provocative piece this week. In the deals space, Groupon has pivoted to a marketplace focus (i.e. normal shopping) and is trading at just $3 a share. Living Social is publicly struggling and experimenting with new models, like card linked offers.
The other deal sites are gone or totally pivoted. Just yesterday, Nimble Commerce, the last of the major independent deal aggregators, announced it was selling out to BlackHawk Network, a leading gift card company.
Other “gimmick commerce” models have also failed to gain traction. The flash sales space is basically gone, with Fab, Gilt, Ziulily bowing out at fire sale prices, and One Kings Lane positioning itself to do the same. Del Rey concludes that none of these companies have been able to cut into the Amazon behemoth, which accounted for 50 percent of all ecommerce growth last year (although Amazon surely engages in its own Gimmick Commerce).
The only companies that are growing and safe from Amazon are the specialty subscription services. With the exception of some of the high loyalty food delivery companies (Blue Apron) and subscription razor companies (Dollar Shave) most of these probably aren’t keeping their customers.
It’s a big, brave thesis. Rey points to the difficulty of building new brands and creating consumer habits from scratch – and the never receding desire to buy everything from a single source. But it is kind of broad — I don’t know that all these companies should be lumped together. And it shouldn’t be inferred that the new technologies and features like big data analytics, buy buttons, card linking and targeted offers that act as a foundation for these sites are being rejected. They remain transformative and will probably account for a big percentage of the next generation of impulse buying, if not shopping altogether.